Giving new life to classic old songs

As someone who’s passionate about music, I’ve always gotten a special kick whenever I hear new recordings of favorite classic rock songs that have been enhanced by the presence of guest vocalists.

Bob Dylan (center) flanked by a Who’s Who of rock legends at a 1992 concert

Sometimes this occurs in the studio when an artist has chosen to re-record a track with another famous voice added to the mix. Other times, it’s a live recording from a concert performance, where a celebrity is brought out on stage to do a duet or provide harmonies. In one memorable instance, a half-dozen luminaries joined Bob Dylan on stage taking turns on verses of one of his classic ’60s tunes at an anniversary concert.

Providing a new ingredient in a tried-and-true musical recipe can result in some tasty moments, but it can’t be denied there are examples of this practice that might be called “failed experiments,” when the addition of the guest vocals not only doesn’t add anything but instead diminishes the song in question.

More often than not, though, it can be an exhilarating new wrinkle on an old tune.

I have spent a few hours this past week locating and listening to mostly recent recordings on which vintage artists have successfully infused their classic rock tracks with vocals by other vintage artists. I’ve selected a dozen here for your listening enjoyment, which you can hear by tuning in the Spotify playlist at the end as you read about how these performances came to be.

**************************

“These Days,” Jackson Browne and Gregg Allman, 2014

A special event at the Fox Theatre in Atlanta nine years ago gathered a broad array of musicians to celebrate the songs and voice of Gregg Allman — and just in time, as it turned out, because Allman passed away in 2017 at age 69. Everyone from Susan Tedeschi and Keb’ Mo’ to Vince Gill and Dr. John turned out to offer spirited covers of Allman’s tunes and, in a few cases, sing them with Allman himself. The best of the bunch, in my view, is Jackson Browne’s stunning duet on “These Days.” Browne wrote it when he was just 16, eventually recording it for his 1973 LP “For Everyman,” and Allman recorded his own version for his solo debut “Laid Back,” which was released almost simultaneously. “He made that song twice as good as it was before,” said Browne of his friend’s rendition. More than 40 years later, they teamed up to perform the song together, using Allman’s arrangement. It appears on the 2014 release “All My Friends: Celebrating the Songs and Voice of Gregg Allman.”

“You’ve Got a Friend,” James Taylor and Carole King, 2007/2010

Taylor and King first met in 1969 in L.A. and musically bonded almost immediately. By 1970, King was playing piano on Taylor’s breakthrough “Sweet Baby James” LP, and they ended up performing together at The Troubadour club in Hollywood that year. When Taylor heard King working on songs that would appear on her upcoming “Tapestry” album, he was knocked out by “You’ve Got a Friend” and asked if he could record it as well, and she graciously agreed. Taylor’s rendition became an enormous #1 hit in 1971 from his “Mud Slide Slim” LP. In 2007, to celebrate the 50th anniversary of The Troubadour, Taylor and King reunited there for six historic shows, and their “Live at the Troubadour” album came out three years later as they mounted a hugely successful reunion tour. They took turns performing their old songs, and then did a heartfelt collaboration on “You’ve Got a Friend” near the end.

“Black Water,” The Doobie Brothers with The Zac Brown Band, 2014

Back in 1974, The Doobies released “Another Park, Another Sunday” as their next single, but it didn’t get much attention until radio stations started playing the B-side instead, a country-ish ditty by guitarist Pat Simmons called “Black Water.” It became the group’s first #1 hit and their fourth of 10 Top Twenty hits during their career. In 2014, Simmons, Tom Johnston, Michael McDonald and John McFee chose to invite country artists like Brad Paisley, Toby Keith, Blake Shelton and Sara Evans to join them in the studio for remakes of a dozen of their hits. It’s great fun to hear the whole “Southbound” LP, but for this playlist, I’ve singled out the new version of “Black Water” featuring additional vocals by Zac Brown Band.

“Riders on the Storm,” Ray Manzarek, Carlos Santana and Chester Bennington, 2010

Wondrous guitarist Santana had found a winning formula in 1999 and 2002 when he teamed up on original material with singers like Dave Matthews, Rob Thomas, Michelle Branch and Seal on two successive albums that both topped the charts. In 2010, Santana took a slightly different tack when he released “Guitar Heaven,” an album featuring the maestro covering classic rock songs like “Sunshine Of Your Love,” “While My Guitar Gently Weeps” and “Whole Lotta Love” with a variety of rock vocalists. The whole album is a treat to listen to, but the one that stands out for me is The Doors’ “Riders on the Storm,” on which Doors keyboardist Ray Manzarek provided the underpinning while Linkin Park vocalist Chester Bennington filled in for the late Jim Morrison. It’s a different arrangement, but I think it rivals the 1971 original from The Doors’ “L.A. Woman” album.

“Forever Man,” Eric Clapton with Steve Winwood, 2008/2009

Back in 1966, when Clapton was forming Cream with Jack Bruce and Ginger Baker, he hoped to bring Winwood into the band as well, but the keyboardist/vocalist was in the midst of forming Traffic and declined. Three years later, Clapton and Winwood managed to join forces as Blind Faith, but that lasted for only one album and a short tour. Each musician went his own way for decades, each enjoying successful solo careers before finally reuniting in 2008 for a much-acclaimed extravaganza at Madison Square Garden. They performed more than 20 songs from throughout their careers, including some Blind Faith tracks and Traffic and Cream classics, and released 21 songs on a live LP in 2009. One of the album’s gems is “Forever Man,” a Clapton solo single that reached #26 in 1985 (and #1 on the Mainstream Rock Tracks chart ) and is augmented here by Winwood’s fine vocals on alternating verses.

“Questions,” Stephen Stills with Judy Collins, 2017

The star-crossed career arc of Buffalo Springfield ended in 1968 with their third and final album, “Last Time Around,” on which most tracks were recorded separately without the full band together. One of those was Stills’ tune “Questions,” virtually a solo song. Stills re-purposed sections of it for the second half of the Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young track “Carry On” on their “Deja Vu” album. Nearly a half-century later, Stills joined up with former paramour Collins (for whom he had written “Suite: Judy Blue Eyes”) for an album, “Everybody Knows,” and a modest tour, and “Questions” was one of the songs Stills chose to include, with Collins adding her distinctive voice.

“Fortunate Son,” John Fogerty with Bruce Springsteen and The E Street Band, 2009

The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Foundation was founded in 1984, and its Museum opened in Cleveland in 1995. A quarter-century after its founding, the Foundation staged two All-star shows at Madison Square Garden to commemorate the milestone, and a multi-CD collection came out a few moths later. The headliners — Stevie Wonder, U2, Jeff Beck, Aretha Franklin, Crosby Stills and Nash, Paul Simon, Metallica and Springsteen — each invited various other Hall of Fame inductees to participate with them on various classic rock tracks. During Springsteen’s set the first night, the great John Fogerty of Creedence Clearwater Revival took the stage and delivered an impassioned reading of the CCR anti-war screed “Fortunate Son” (a #3 hit in 1969) with The E Street Band providing some stellar backup, including Springsteen’s vocals.

“Gimme Shelter,” The Rolling Stones with Lady Gaga, 2012/2023

In 2012-13, The Stones mounted their “50 and Counting” tour, marking their 50 years in the music business. Their December 2012 show in Newark was originally recorded for a pay-per-view concert, then remixed and released 10 years later in February 2023. The band had invited a few guests to appear on selected songs, including John Mayer, Gary Clark, The Black Keys and Bruce Springsteen. By far the most riveting performance came from Lady Gaga, who was still a relative newcomer at that point with just two albums out (although both multi-platinum). She came on early in the proceedings to handle the female vocal part on “Gimme Shelter,” performed so superbly by Merry Clayton in 1969 on the “Let It Bleed” album.

“Mother and Child Reunion,” Paul Simon with Jimmy Cliff, 2012/2017

Simon had been intrigued with the rhythms coming out of Jamaica in the late ’60s, and made a half-hearted attempt at a reggae song with Art Garfunkel called “Why Don’t You Write Me” on their “Bridge Over Troubled Water” album. Two years later, he wisely concluded that if he wanted to nail the Jamaican rhythms accurately, he needed to go to the source. He flew to Kingston and hired reggae star Jimmy Cliff’s band to record “Mother and Child Reunion” with him for his “Paul Simon” solo debut, and the single reached #4 in early 1972. It has been a regular part of his concert repertoire over the years, but in 2012 at a concert in Hyde Park in London, he brought Jimmy Cliff himself on stage to flesh out the vocal harmonies on the song. A CD/DVD of the show was released in 2017.

“Let It Be,” Dolly Parton and Paul McCartney, 2023

Last year, Parton said she felt sheepish and uncomfortable when notifgied she was being inducted into the Rockm and Roll Hall of Fame. She’s a titanic star of country music, of course, and has maybe a half-dozen songs in her recorded catalog that might be loosely described as rock, but she didn’t feel deserving of the honor. “If I’m going to be inducted, I’m going to need to make a rock and roll album,” she insisted, and set out to do just that. “Rockstar,” due for release in November, will include 30 selections involving everyone from Sting and Elton John to Miley Cyrus and Joan Jett. The preview single released last week pairs Parton with Paul McCartney on “Let It Be,” also featuring Ringo Starr on drums and Peter Frampton on guitar. It’s an exciting arrangement nicely executed.

“Luck Be a Lady,” Frank Sinatra with Chrissie Hynde, 1994

Sinatra was in his mid-70s when he was approached by his record label about putting together a record of duets with easy-listening peers and contemporary artists. He liked the concept, and lined up an impressive list of singers who were eager to participate, but he got cold feet when the time came to enter the studio. He had always been very particular about who was in the room when he was being recorded and, ultimately, he decided that he would sing the songs by himself with an orchestra and his duet partners would be recorded remotely and added after the fact, which has only recently become technically possible. Among the contemporary artists who “phoned in” their parts for Sinatra’s “Duets” (1993) and “Duets II” (1994) LPs were Willie Nelson, Jimmy Buffett, Bono and Aretha Franklin. I’m partial to The Pretenders’ Chrissie Hynde’s contribution to “Luck Be a Lady” from the second collection.

“My Back Pages,” Bob Dylan with Roger McGuinn, Tom Petty, Neil Young, Eric Clapton, George Harrison, 1992/1993

In 1992, the typically taciturn Dylan agreed to be feted at a commemorative concert celebrating his 30th anniversary as a recording artist.  An extraordinary array of artists descended on Madison Square Garden to perform 30 Dylan songs from throughout his career — hits and obscure tracks, chestnuts and recent tunes.  Among the 75 different musicians and singers on stage at various points of the evening that night were Stevie Wonder, Lou Reed, Chrissie Hynde, Richie Havens, Johnny Winter, Tracy Chapman, Eddie Vedder, Johnny Cash, Mary Chapin-Carpenter and John Mellencamp.  As the show drew to a close, Dylan came out to perform three songs, and the best of these, the prescient “My Back Pages,” featured Roger McGuinn, Tom Petty, Neil Young, Eric Clapton, George Harrison and Dylan each taking a verse.  It’s a thrilling confluence of talent sharing the spotlight on an iconic song from 1964. The CD was released in 1993, with a deluxe CD/DVD package re-released in 2014.

***************************

I know what I know

It’s been a while since I’ve tested my readers’ grasp of arcane information about artists, albums and songs from the classic rock era. I fully recognize that I’ve had an Uber-passionate (some might say excessive) interest in such things since I was in middle school, and most of you won’t have a clue about most of these 15 classic rock trivia questions. Nevertheless, let’s give it the old college try, shall we?

Consider these questions I’ve posed, ruminate on them a bit, and jot down your best guesses. Then scroll down to see the answers and, in the process, learn a thing or two about these artists, albums and songs. As always, there’s also a Spotify playlist at the end that includes the pertinent songs referred to in the questions.

Who can get 5 out of 15? Or maybe 10? Or even all 15? Anybody?

*****************************

1 Which artist has NOT recorded a song with Paul McCartney?

a) Steve Miller

b) Elvis Costello

c) Don Henley

d) Carl Perkins

2 Which of these hit singles was written by Randy Newman?

a) Brewer & Shipley’s “One Toke Over the Line”

b) Three Dog Night’s “Mama Told Me Not to Come”

c) Mungo Jerry’s “In the Summertime”

d) J Geils Band’s “Centerfold”

3 Which John Lennon solo song was originally intended to be a Beatles track under another title with different lyrics?

a) “Mind Games”

b) “Working Class Hero”

c) “Jealous Guy”

d) “Instant Karma”

4 Only one of these four James Taylor hit singles was written by Taylor. Which one?

a) “You’ve Got a Friend”

b) “Handy Man”

c) “How Sweet It Is (To Be Loved By You)”

d) “Don’t Let Me Be Lonely Tonight”

5 Which song does NOT include the word “fuck” in the lyrics?

a) “Woman of Heart and Mind,” Joni Mitchell

b) “We Can Be Together,” Jefferson Airplane

c) “Love in an Elevator,” Aerosmith

d) “Show Biz Kids,” Steely Dan

6 Which song was a bigger hit on the charts in its live version than in its studio version?

a) “Start Me Up,” The Rolling Stones

b) “Rock and Roll All Nite,” Kiss

c) “Freebird,” Lynyrd Skynyrd

d) “Domino,” Van Morrison

7 Which guitarist never appeared on a Steely Dan record?

a) Rick Derringer

b) Mark Knopfler

c) Jeff Beck

d) Steve Khan

8 What was Tina Turner’s real name?

a) Florence Matthews

b) Anna Mae Bullock

c) Shirley Washington

d) Delilah King

9 Which Beatles single failed to reach the Top Ten on the US charts?

a) “Nowhere Man”

b) “Lady Madonna”

c) “And I Love Her”

d) “The Ballad of John and Yoko”

10 Who played the pedal steel guitar part on Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young’s hit “Teach Your Children”?

a) Rusty Young of Poco

b) Jerry Garcia of The Grateful Dead

c) Toy Caldwell of The Marshall Tucker Band

d) Pete Drake, Nashville session musician

11 On which Bob Dylan album did Johnny Cash make an appearance?

a) “New Morning”

b) “John Wesley Harding”

c) “Nashville Skyline”

d) “Blood on the Tracks”

12 Who has never been a member of Bruce Springsteen’s E Street Band?

a) Vini Lopez

b) David Sancious

c) Nils Lofgren

d) Southside Johnny Lyon

13 Which song has reached #1 on US charts by two different artists?

a) “The Letter”

b) “Venus”

c) “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough”

d) “Summertime Blues”

14 What is Bono’s real name?

a) Henry Deutschendorf

b) Paul Hewson

c) Thomas Shelby

d) Ivan Byrne

15 Which of these highly regarded live albums charted the highest in the US?

a) “Europe ’72,” Grateful Dead

b) “At Fillmore East,” The Allman Brothers Band

c) “Rock of Ages,” The Band

d) “Waiting For Columbus,” Little Feat

**************************

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

ANSWERS:

1 McCartney has never collaborated with Don Henley. Paul recorded and co-wrote several songs with Elvis Costello, notably “You Want Her Too” on Paul’s “Flowers in the Dirt” album and “Veronica” on Costello’s “Spike” LP. He recorded and co-wrote the blues track “Used to Be Bad” with Steve Miller on Paul’s 1997 album “Flaming Pie.” He also recorded with Carl Perkins, a country-picking tune called “Get It” from the celebrated 1982 LP “Tug of War.”

2 Newman wrote “Mama Told Me Not to Come” in 1967 for former Animals lead singer Eric Burdon, who recorded it for his “Eric is Here” solo debut. Newman recorded it himself for his “12 Songs” album in 1970, the same year that Three Dog Night’s rendition reached #1 on US pop charts. (“One Toke Over the Line” was written by Mike Brewer and Tom Shipley; “In the Summertime” was penned by Ray Dorset, lead singer for Mungo Jerry; and “Centerfold” was composed by J Geils band keyboard player Seth Justman.)

3 Upon returning from their meditation retreat in India in spring 1968, The Beatles made demos of a couple dozen songs, many of which ended up on The White Album. Lennon wrote a tune he originally titled “Child of Nature,” inspired by Maharishi’s lectures, but since Paul had written “Mother Nature’s Son” around the same time, Lennon shelved his song for a few years, resurrecting it during sessions for his “Imagine” album in 1971. He wrote a new set of lyrics confessing his propensity to be jealous, and entitled it “Jealous Guy.”

4 “Don’t Let Me Be Lonely Tonight” is a Taylor original, recorded in 1972 for his “One Man Dog” album. “You’ve Got a Friend” is Carole King’s song, which she also recorded on her 1971 LP “Tapestry.” “Handy Man” was co-written by Otis Blackwell and Jimmy Jones, and recorded by Jones in 1959. “How Sweet It Is” was written by the Motown songwriting team of Eddie Holland, Lamont Dozier and Brian Holland and recorded first by Marvin Gaye in 1965.

5 Aerosmith’s “Love in an Elevator” was a #5 hit in 1989 about wanting to have sex while riding an elevator, but the f-bomb doesn’t appear in the lyrics. Joni Mitchell dared use it in a dramatic way in her 1972 song to criticize the hollowness of a man who would “drive your bargains, push your papers, win your medals, fuck your strangers, don’t it leave you on the empty side…”. In 1969, Paul Kantner of Jefferson Airplane used the ’60s protest slogan “Up against the wall, motherfucker” in the lyrics of his utopian screed “We Can Be Together” on their “Volunteers” LP. Steely Dan’s songwriting team of Donald Fagen and Walter Becker wrote “Show Biz Kids” in 1973 as a scathing indictment of the narcissism inherent in the Hollywood elite: “Show business kids making movies of themselves, you know they don’t give a fuck about anybody else…”

6 Kiss first released “Rock and Roll All Nite” as a single from its “Dressed to Kill” album in early 1975, but it stalled at #68. Six months later, their “Alive!” LP was released and a live version of the song reached #12 on US charts in 1976. The Rolling Stones included live versions of “Start Me Up” on four different live LPs but none were released as a single, while the studio recording was a huge #1 hit in 1981. “Domino” was a #9 hit for Van Morrison in 1970, and although he recorded a live version for his “It’s Too Late to Stop Now” in 1974, it was not released as a single. Lynyrd Skynyrd’s “Freebird” was issued as a single in its 1976 live version, but it peaked at #38 while the original topped out at #19 in 1974.

7 Although it would’ve been an intriguing idea to bring Jeff Beck in for a solo on a Steely Dan track, he never made an appearance. Rick Derringer was a guest two times for the band on the 1973 tune “Show Biz Kids” and the 1975 “Katy Lied” track “Chain Lightning.” Mark Knopfler of Dire Straits took time off in 1980 to provide some tasty guitar licks on “Time Out of Mind” from the “Gaucho” LP. Jazz guitarist Steve Khan played on a half-dozen tracks on “Aja” and “Gaucho.”

8 Florence Matthews, Shirley Washington and Delilah King are names I made up. Tina Turner’s given name was Anna Mae Bullock.

9 “And I Love Her,” a McCartney ballad from the “A Hard Day’s Night” soundtrack in 1964, missed the US Top Ten, peaking at #12. “Nowhere Man” (#3 in 1965), “Lady Madonna” (#4 in 1968) and “The Ballad of John and Yoko” (#8 in 1969) all managed to reach the Top Ten here.

10 The Grateful Dead and CSN&Y (especially David Crosby and Neil Young) had a simpatico relationship in 1969-70, and it made perfect sense for Graham Nash to recruit Jerry Garcia for the “Teach Your Children” session. Actually, Rusty Young would have been a logical possibility, seeing as how Poco was born from ashes of Stephen Stills’ old band Buffalo Springfield… Pete Drake was in demand as the cream of pedal steel players, but he wasn’t conveniently located in LA, where sessions were held. Same with South Carolina-based Toy Caldwell, whose group, The Marshall Tucker Band, didn’t emerge until two years later in 1972.

11 It stands to reason that Nashville-based Johnny Cash would show up on “Nashville Skyline,” recorded in the Music City in 1969 using Nashville musicians. Cash and Dylan recorded an unvarnished take on the 1963 Dylan song “Girl From the North Country.” It’s not inconceivable Cash could’ve showed up on 1968’s “John Wesley Harding,” also recorded in Nashville, or even on the country-flavored “New Morning” in 1971, even though it was recorded in New York. It’s far less likely that Cash would’ve been collaborating on Dylan’s highly personal LP “Blood on the Tracks” in 1974…

12 Southside Johnny Lyon was a close friend of Springsteen from their days playing clubs along the Jersey shore, and Springsteen contributed a half-dozen original songs to Southside’s repertoire, but Lyon never spent time as a member of The E Street Band. Vini Lopez and David Sancious were the original drummer and piano player in Springsteen’s band, heard on the 1973 LP “The Wild, the Innocent and The E Street Shuffle.” Lopez was let go in favor of Max Weinberg, while Sancious sought a solo career and was replaced by Roy Bittan. Nils Lofgren joined The E Street Band in 1984 as Steve Van Zandt’s replacement and has been in the lineup ever since (even after Van Zandt returned).

13 “The Letter” was a huge #1 hit in its first incarnation by The Box Tops in 1967, but Joe Cocker’s exuberant remake in 1970 topped out at #7. Diana Ross’s melodramatic rendition of “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough” was a big #1 debut hit for her in 1970, but the original arrangement in 1967 featuring Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell managed only #19. “Summertime Blues” reached #8 in 1958 for Eddie Cochran, #14 for Blue Cheer in 1968, #27 for The Who in 1970, but never #1 (although it became a #1 country chart hit for Alan Jackson in 1994). “Venus” is the winner, reaching #1 for Shocking Blue in 1970 and #1 again in 1986 for Bananarama. What’s more, there’s an entirely different song with the same “Venus” title that reached #1 for Frankie Avalon in 1959.

14 Paul Hewson had a number of nicknames during his Dublin upbringing, including Bon Murray and Bono Vox of O’Connell Street, before settling on just Bono in 1975. The name Henry Deutschendorf is the given name of John Denver. The name Thomas Shelby will be familiar to viewers of the Netflix series “Peaky Blinders” as the lead character. Ivan Byrne? Made that one up.

15 After a few iconic studio albums that reached the Top Ten, the timing was perfect for the release of The Band’s “Rock of Ages,” their extraordinary 1972 live album that capitalized on their then-current popularity and peaked at #6 on US album charts. The Grateful Dead’s excellent live triple-LP “Europe ’72” leveled off at #24 in 1972; Little Feat’s awesome “Waiting for Columbus” in 1978 plateaued at #18. Even my favorite live album of all time — “The Allman Brothers At Fillmore East” — peaked at #13.

*********************************