When you raise the roof with your rock ‘n’ roll

In 1967, at age 12, I persuaded my parents to get me an electric guitar for Christmas.  I was one of apparently hundreds of thousands of young American boys who wanted to get together with a handful of like-minded friends and start a band.

c1f394c876fc6da701266c568ab30f1d

I took lessons, learned a few chords, and saved up money to buy a small amplifier.  I was now equipped to thrash my way through a few basic rock songs like “Gloria” and “Hey Joe” with my drummer friend Paul.  Later, I joined forces with my buddy Steve on bass, Andy on lead guitar, and Tim on drums (Paul had moved).  We called ourselves Phoenix.

Like so many other rudimentary bands across the country, we would practice in basements (if our parents could tolerate the noise) or in garages (where we were out of earshot).  We tried mightily to get proficient enough to play in front of friends at school variety shows or YMCA dances or “Battle of the Bands” parties.

It was thrilling, even though we weren’t very good.

Some of these rough-edged groups practicing in garages nationwide were lucky enough to have connections, or be discovered, and somehow managed to cut a record that, against all odds, got played on the local AM rock and roll station.  An even smaller segment watched dumbfounded as their record received regional and then national airplay.  Probably less than one tenth of 1% achieved the holy grail:  Their record made it into the Billboard Top Ten pop charts!

Rock historians now look back at the transitional period from roughly 1965 through 1968 as the era of “garage rock” — although it wasn’t called that at the time.

As Wikipedia defines it, garage rock “often sounded amateurish, naive or intentionally raw… The lyrics and the delivery were frequently more aggressive than the polished acts of the time, often with nasal, growled or shouted vocals punctuated by shrieks and screams…  Instrumentation was characterized by basic chord structures played on keyboards and electric guitars, often deliberately distorted through a fuzzbox.”

Keep in mind, rock music was only 10-12 years old, still finding its way, redefining itself after its initial birth (1955-1959) and subsequent pillaging/whitewashing by corporate record labels (1959-1963).  Then the Beatles and other “British Invasion” bands arrived, re-interpreted American blues songs and artists, and gave American kids a schooling in the roots music they’d forgotten or never learned.

98fdbd22b1f27cf54f97f736e46f12c4

And suddenly, everybody wanted to be in a band.  In the Pacific Northwest, in Texas, in the Midwest, in New Jersey, in southern California, groups huddled in garages and worked on covers of their favorite songs, or maybe they tried writing their own stuff.  Most were hopeless, but some had something intangible that clicked.

Rock historian Gary Stewart summed it up this way:  “Although most of these kids wanted to be The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, The Yardbirds, The Kinks, The Animals… few had anywhere near the talent to deliver the goods.  But what they had was passion, informed by a heavy dose of unmitigated gall, and naivete, and attitude to spare.”

If I rattled off the names of some of these bands, you might recognize a few:  The Barbarians, The Choir, Count Five, The Leaves, The Swingin’ Medallions, The Thirteenth Floor Elevators, Syndicate of Sound, The Electric Prunes.

Or maybe a couple song titles will ring a bell:  “Pushin’ Too Hard,” “96 Tears,” “Oh Yeah,” “Nobody But Me,” “Night Time,” “Little Bit o’ Soul,” “Farmer John,” “Beg, Borrow and Steal.”

Or possibly you won’t know the band, the title or even the song itself because it barely made a dent and was soon forgotten (“Let’s Talk About Girls” by The Chocolate Watchband).

5bb49d924f8eec3a291f998324016957

But thanks to Lenny Kaye (who went on to become the guitarist in The Patti Smith Group), and Jac Holzman (founder of Elektra Records), an incredible collection of garage rock gems exists:  “Nuggets:  Original Artyfacts from the First Psychedelic Era, 1965-1968,” first released in 1972, is a loving, 27-song compilation that provides an excellent overview of the period.  Critics have praised it as one of the best retrospectives in rock history.

There were supposed to be additional volumes, but those never surfaced…until 1998, when “Nuggets” was re-released as a 4-CD package, expanding the song list to more than 100 tracks, which should be a real treasure trove to any devotee of roots rock.

As Kaye put it in the liner notes, “These records’ lasting impact comes not in spite of their creators’ limitations, but because of them.  What defines the garage-rock era more than anything else is not knowing any better — and even more important, not caring.  The new package consists of 118 tracks which, when combined, took less time to record and mix than one CD would now.”

Garage rock was attitude over aptitude — snotty and arrogant, fueled by fuzz and frustration, with usually stupid lyrics, but just enough skill to produce catchy riffs or choruses, and the desire to pull it off convincingly.

The records were innovative, especially in the way they were recorded:  quickly, almost carelessly, with maybe one or two microphones, lots of echo, miscellaneous studio noise and, of course, all in one take, maybe two.  There was diversity, too; some of these tracks showed R&B elements of Memphis and Motown, some offered three-part Beach-Boys harmonies, others presaged the acid rock of Hendrix and Cream.

In ’72, Kaye referred to this music as “punk,” first used by critics in 1965 to describe brash, petulant bands like ? and the Mysterians.  But by 1976, the punk rock movement in London, New York and Los Angeles had hijacked that term for themselves, so instead, historians started using the terms “garage rock” and “garage bands” to describe the 1965-1968 period.  And actually, ’70s punk rockers, ’80s New Wave artists and ’90s grunge bands have often mentioned ’60s garage rock music — specific songs and bands, and in general — as being deeply influential.

So here are 20 garage rock classics, hand-picked by Hack’s Back Pages, most of which appear on “Nuggets.”  If they made the Top 40 charts, I’ve include their peak position in parentheses.  If you came of age in the ’60s or ’70s, some of these are bound to stir a memory or two.

*************************

71uLfVEgJpL._SX355_

“Wild Thing,” The Troggs — Grungy and basic, this song is a shining example of the genre, and one of the only British contributions.  One of only two or three to reach the top spot.  (#1)

“Pushin’ Too Hard,” The Seeds — Led by the great Sky Saxon (born Richie Marsh), this L.A. band is a favorite of critics and fans of psychedelic-era music, thanks to a half-dozen regional singles (“Mr. Farmer,” “A Thousand Shadows”) and a couple of milestone albums.

“It’s Cold Outside,” The Choir — In December 1966 (when it was cold outside, appropriately), the Cleveland-based group enjoyed this one regional hit (#1 in the Midwest, bumping The Beatles out of the top spot, but only #68 nationally).  Several band members went on to form the ’70s pop group The Raspberries.

“Lies,” The Knickerbockers — This is a spot-on Beatles middle-period knockoff with a brash edge to it, certainly rougher and more in-your-face than any Fab Four recording.  You can hear both Lennon and McCartney mimicked by the group’s two singers.  (#20)

R-1229617-1202258614.jpeg

“Dirty Water,” The Standells — A personal favorite (and one of my go-to karaoke choices), this infectious track about Boston actually comes from an L.A.-based band.  It’s still played today during Red Sox games.  (#11)

“You’re Gonna Miss Me,” The Thirteenth Floor Elevators — One of the first bands to emerge nationally from the musically rich Austin, Texas, area, this prototype psychedelic group caught on in Houston and Dallas in 1966 before winning coveted warm-up assignments at The Fillmore for California bands like Moby Grape and Quicksilver Messenger Service.

“The Little Black Egg,” The Nightcrawlers — Described by one critic as a “rather bizarre nursery rhyme,” this tune did well in Florida and the Midwest but stiffed nationally.  Still, many garage bands added it to their required repertoire.

“Are You a Boy or Are You a Girl?” The Barbarians — This California band got its lucky break appearing on the widely praised “The T.A.M.I. Show” concert film in Santa Monica in 1964 alongside The Rolling Stones and James Brown, largely on the strength of this single, even though it stalled at #55.

MI0000240213

“Liar, Liar,” The Castaways — As you can see from the photo at left, these Minnesotans were still in high school (maybe middle school?) when they cut this irresistible, organ-dominated track.  They would never be heard from again.  (#12)

“Psychotic Reaction,” Count Five — In a psychology class at San Jose City College in 1965, aspiring musician Sean Byrne decided “Psychotic Reaction” would be a great name for a song, and with the help of his friends in the fledgling band Count Five, he came up with the track that is widely considered the first acid rock single, modeled after early Yardbirds material.  (#5)

“Little Girl,” Syndicate of Sound — Another band out of San Jose was this group who won a “Battle of the Bands” competition and a recording contract, which resulted in this Top Ten single.  They toured behind Paul Revere & The Raiders and The Young Rascals, but their moment in the sun faded quickly.  (#8)

“Let’s Talk About Girls,” The Chocolate Watchband — This Bay Area group went through numerous personnel changes and were recruited by Fillmore promoter Bill Graham to hitch their wagon to The Grateful Dead’s rising fame, but they instead moved to L.A., where they recorded a couple albums and singles that went nowhere, although this psychedelic track was wildly popular in California in 1967.

maxresdefault

“She’s About a Mover,” Sir Douglas Quintet — The Vox Continental organ riff that dominates this track took it into the national Top 20 for this Texas-based band, who deftly merged R&B, Tex-Mex and British blues styles.  They relocated to San Francisco, released four LPs and a half-dozen singles, and stayed active on the club circuit throughout the ’70s.  (#13)

“So What!!” The Lyrics — This angry, harmonica-led garage rocker from a San Diego band ranted about the school’s rich girl and all her trappings:   Well, I guess there ain’t too much you haven’t got, well, all I can say to you about that is ‘So what??’…”

“Nobody But Me,” The Human Beinz — From Youngstown, Ohio, came this foursome who took an obscure Isley Brothers song from 1962, updated it for the garage-rock era, and had their only Top Ten hit.  It holds the record for most repetitions of a word in the lyrics (“No” is said 31 times in succession).  The track appeared in Quentin Tarantino’s “Kill Bill: Vol 1” (2004) and Martin Scorsese’s “The Departed” (2006).  (#8)

“I Had Too Much to Dream Last Night,” The Electric Prunes — Ooh, drugs, man.  This was the definitive Top 40 version of an LSD trip, complete with undulating guitar parts and cosmic lyrics.  The best example of the psychedelic arm in the “Nuggets” collection, and a big seller as well.  (#11)

49cbd12c88785ec22bb2b14bb9602966

“Little Bit o’ Soul,” The Music Explosion — Emerging from the small town of Mansfield, Ohio, this one-shot group exceeded their wildest expectations with their slurred vocals and cheesy Farfisa organ to flirt with the top of the charts in early 1967. (#2)

“Night Time,” The Strangeloves — A trio of New York-based songwriters who had written such hits as “My Boyfriend’s Back” in the early ’60s came up with the material and recorded anonymously as The Strangeloves, scoring a Top Ten hit in 1964 called ” I Want Candy.”  They sent other musicians on tour in their place, and scored more hit singles like “Night Time” in 1965 before giving up the gig and becoming celebrated producers in the ’70s and ’80s. (#30)

“Oh Yeah,” The Shadows of Knight — The great Van Morrison, with his band Them, wrote and recorded the classic “Gloria,” but it was the more lightweight version by Chicago-based The Shadows of Knight that most American listeners bought, sending it to #10 (and to #1 in several major markets).  Its follow-up, the riotous “Oh Yeah,” was far less successful but still loads of fun. (#39)

quesspanep

“96 Tears,” ? and the Mysterians — Speaking of Farfisa organ, this track is the undisputed king of that instrument on the charts.  I’m not even sure there’s guitar on this track, the organ dominates so completely, along with the half-talked vocal by a guy who, even now, goes by the name Question Mark.  “96 Tears” held the #1 spot in the US in October 1966.

*********

If the definition of garage rock is expanded to include any band that ever rehearsed or recorded in a garage, that might include about 80% of all rock bands.  It’s certainly valid to point out that, for musicians who form a band with dreams of becoming famous, making a start in someone’s garage has a proud and noble history — and a future, for that matter.

Dave Grohl, guitarist of The Foo Fighters and former drummer for Nirvana, encourages kids to think positive and pursue their dream, even if it starts in a garage.

“Young musicians should go to a yard sale and buy an old drum set,” he says, “and get in their garage and just suck.  And get their friends to come in, and they’ll suck, too.  And then they’ll start playing, and start getting better, and they’ll have the best time they’ve ever had in their lives, and then all of a sudden they’ll be on the radio.  Because that’s exactly what happened with Nirvana.  Just a bunch of guys that had some shitty old instruments, and they got together and started playing some noisy-ass shit, and they became the biggest band in the world.”

Grohl adds, “There’s a band somewhere in a garage right now writing songs that will do the same thing “Nevermind” did for Nirvana 25 years ago.  We don’t know who or where, but it will f–king happen again.  All it takes is for that storm to break.”

********************************

Giving new life to classic old songs

As someone who’s passionate about music, I’ve always gotten a special kick whenever I hear new recordings of favorite classic rock songs that have been enhanced by the presence of guest vocalists.

Bob Dylan (center) flanked by a Who’s Who of rock legends at a 1992 concert

Sometimes this occurs in the studio when an artist has chosen to re-record a track with another famous voice added to the mix. Other times, it’s a live recording from a concert performance, where a celebrity is brought out on stage to do a duet or provide harmonies. In one memorable instance, a half-dozen luminaries joined Bob Dylan on stage taking turns on verses of one of his classic ’60s tunes at an anniversary concert.

Providing a new ingredient in a tried-and-true musical recipe can result in some tasty moments, but it can’t be denied there are examples of this practice that might be called “failed experiments,” when the addition of the guest vocals not only doesn’t add anything but instead diminishes the song in question.

More often than not, though, it can be an exhilarating new wrinkle on an old tune.

I have spent a few hours this past week locating and listening to mostly recent recordings on which vintage artists have successfully infused their classic rock tracks with vocals by other vintage artists. I’ve selected a dozen here for your listening enjoyment, which you can hear by tuning in the Spotify playlist at the end as you read about how these performances came to be.

**************************

“These Days,” Jackson Browne and Gregg Allman, 2014

A special event at the Fox Theatre in Atlanta nine years ago gathered a broad array of musicians to celebrate the songs and voice of Gregg Allman — and just in time, as it turned out, because Allman passed away in 2017 at age 69. Everyone from Susan Tedeschi and Keb’ Mo’ to Vince Gill and Dr. John turned out to offer spirited covers of Allman’s tunes and, in a few cases, sing them with Allman himself. The best of the bunch, in my view, is Jackson Browne’s stunning duet on “These Days.” Browne wrote it when he was just 16, eventually recording it for his 1973 LP “For Everyman,” and Allman recorded his own version for his solo debut “Laid Back,” which was released almost simultaneously. “He made that song twice as good as it was before,” said Browne of his friend’s rendition. More than 40 years later, they teamed up to perform the song together, using Allman’s arrangement. It appears on the 2014 release “All My Friends: Celebrating the Songs and Voice of Gregg Allman.”

“You’ve Got a Friend,” James Taylor and Carole King, 2007/2010

Taylor and King first met in 1969 in L.A. and musically bonded almost immediately. By 1970, King was playing piano on Taylor’s breakthrough “Sweet Baby James” LP, and they ended up performing together at The Troubadour club in Hollywood that year. When Taylor heard King working on songs that would appear on her upcoming “Tapestry” album, he was knocked out by “You’ve Got a Friend” and asked if he could record it as well, and she graciously agreed. Taylor’s rendition became an enormous #1 hit in 1971 from his “Mud Slide Slim” LP. In 2007, to celebrate the 50th anniversary of The Troubadour, Taylor and King reunited there for six historic shows, and their “Live at the Troubadour” album came out three years later as they mounted a hugely successful reunion tour. They took turns performing their old songs, and then did a heartfelt collaboration on “You’ve Got a Friend” near the end.

“Black Water,” The Doobie Brothers with The Zac Brown Band, 2014

Back in 1974, The Doobies released “Another Park, Another Sunday” as their next single, but it didn’t get much attention until radio stations started playing the B-side instead, a country-ish ditty by guitarist Pat Simmons called “Black Water.” It became the group’s first #1 hit and their fourth of 10 Top Twenty hits during their career. In 2014, Simmons, Tom Johnston, Michael McDonald and John McFee chose to invite country artists like Brad Paisley, Toby Keith, Blake Shelton and Sara Evans to join them in the studio for remakes of a dozen of their hits. It’s great fun to hear the whole “Southbound” LP, but for this playlist, I’ve singled out the new version of “Black Water” featuring additional vocals by Zac Brown Band.

“Riders on the Storm,” Ray Manzarek, Carlos Santana and Chester Bennington, 2010

Wondrous guitarist Santana had found a winning formula in 1999 and 2002 when he teamed up on original material with singers like Dave Matthews, Rob Thomas, Michelle Branch and Seal on two successive albums that both topped the charts. In 2010, Santana took a slightly different tack when he released “Guitar Heaven,” an album featuring the maestro covering classic rock songs like “Sunshine Of Your Love,” “While My Guitar Gently Weeps” and “Whole Lotta Love” with a variety of rock vocalists. The whole album is a treat to listen to, but the one that stands out for me is The Doors’ “Riders on the Storm,” on which Doors keyboardist Ray Manzarek provided the underpinning while Linkin Park vocalist Chester Bennington filled in for the late Jim Morrison. It’s a different arrangement, but I think it rivals the 1971 original from The Doors’ “L.A. Woman” album.

“Forever Man,” Eric Clapton with Steve Winwood, 2008/2009

Back in 1966, when Clapton was forming Cream with Jack Bruce and Ginger Baker, he hoped to bring Winwood into the band as well, but the keyboardist/vocalist was in the midst of forming Traffic and declined. Three years later, Clapton and Winwood managed to join forces as Blind Faith, but that lasted for only one album and a short tour. Each musician went his own way for decades, each enjoying successful solo careers before finally reuniting in 2008 for a much-acclaimed extravaganza at Madison Square Garden. They performed more than 20 songs from throughout their careers, including some Blind Faith tracks and Traffic and Cream classics, and released 21 songs on a live LP in 2009. One of the album’s gems is “Forever Man,” a Clapton solo single that reached #26 in 1985 (and #1 on the Mainstream Rock Tracks chart ) and is augmented here by Winwood’s fine vocals on alternating verses.

“Questions,” Stephen Stills with Judy Collins, 2017

The star-crossed career arc of Buffalo Springfield ended in 1968 with their third and final album, “Last Time Around,” on which most tracks were recorded separately without the full band together. One of those was Stills’ tune “Questions,” virtually a solo song. Stills re-purposed sections of it for the second half of the Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young track “Carry On” on their “Deja Vu” album. Nearly a half-century later, Stills joined up with former paramour Collins (for whom he had written “Suite: Judy Blue Eyes”) for an album, “Everybody Knows,” and a modest tour, and “Questions” was one of the songs Stills chose to include, with Collins adding her distinctive voice.

“Fortunate Son,” John Fogerty with Bruce Springsteen and The E Street Band, 2009

The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Foundation was founded in 1984, and its Museum opened in Cleveland in 1995. A quarter-century after its founding, the Foundation staged two All-star shows at Madison Square Garden to commemorate the milestone, and a multi-CD collection came out a few moths later. The headliners — Stevie Wonder, U2, Jeff Beck, Aretha Franklin, Crosby Stills and Nash, Paul Simon, Metallica and Springsteen — each invited various other Hall of Fame inductees to participate with them on various classic rock tracks. During Springsteen’s set the first night, the great John Fogerty of Creedence Clearwater Revival took the stage and delivered an impassioned reading of the CCR anti-war screed “Fortunate Son” (a #3 hit in 1969) with The E Street Band providing some stellar backup, including Springsteen’s vocals.

“Gimme Shelter,” The Rolling Stones with Lady Gaga, 2012/2023

In 2012-13, The Stones mounted their “50 and Counting” tour, marking their 50 years in the music business. Their December 2012 show in Newark was originally recorded for a pay-per-view concert, then remixed and released 10 years later in February 2023. The band had invited a few guests to appear on selected songs, including John Mayer, Gary Clark, The Black Keys and Bruce Springsteen. By far the most riveting performance came from Lady Gaga, who was still a relative newcomer at that point with just two albums out (although both multi-platinum). She came on early in the proceedings to handle the female vocal part on “Gimme Shelter,” performed so superbly by Merry Clayton in 1969 on the “Let It Bleed” album.

“Mother and Child Reunion,” Paul Simon with Jimmy Cliff, 2012/2017

Simon had been intrigued with the rhythms coming out of Jamaica in the late ’60s, and made a half-hearted attempt at a reggae song with Art Garfunkel called “Why Don’t You Write Me” on their “Bridge Over Troubled Water” album. Two years later, he wisely concluded that if he wanted to nail the Jamaican rhythms accurately, he needed to go to the source. He flew to Kingston and hired reggae star Jimmy Cliff’s band to record “Mother and Child Reunion” with him for his “Paul Simon” solo debut, and the single reached #4 in early 1972. It has been a regular part of his concert repertoire over the years, but in 2012 at a concert in Hyde Park in London, he brought Jimmy Cliff himself on stage to flesh out the vocal harmonies on the song. A CD/DVD of the show was released in 2017.

“Let It Be,” Dolly Parton and Paul McCartney, 2023

Last year, Parton said she felt sheepish and uncomfortable when notifgied she was being inducted into the Rockm and Roll Hall of Fame. She’s a titanic star of country music, of course, and has maybe a half-dozen songs in her recorded catalog that might be loosely described as rock, but she didn’t feel deserving of the honor. “If I’m going to be inducted, I’m going to need to make a rock and roll album,” she insisted, and set out to do just that. “Rockstar,” due for release in November, will include 30 selections involving everyone from Sting and Elton John to Miley Cyrus and Joan Jett. The preview single released last week pairs Parton with Paul McCartney on “Let It Be,” also featuring Ringo Starr on drums and Peter Frampton on guitar. It’s an exciting arrangement nicely executed.

“Luck Be a Lady,” Frank Sinatra with Chrissie Hynde, 1994

Sinatra was in his mid-70s when he was approached by his record label about putting together a record of duets with easy-listening peers and contemporary artists. He liked the concept, and lined up an impressive list of singers who were eager to participate, but he got cold feet when the time came to enter the studio. He had always been very particular about who was in the room when he was being recorded and, ultimately, he decided that he would sing the songs by himself with an orchestra and his duet partners would be recorded remotely and added after the fact, which has only recently become technically possible. Among the contemporary artists who “phoned in” their parts for Sinatra’s “Duets” (1993) and “Duets II” (1994) LPs were Willie Nelson, Jimmy Buffett, Bono and Aretha Franklin. I’m partial to The Pretenders’ Chrissie Hynde’s contribution to “Luck Be a Lady” from the second collection.

“My Back Pages,” Bob Dylan with Roger McGuinn, Tom Petty, Neil Young, Eric Clapton, George Harrison, 1992/1993

In 1992, the typically taciturn Dylan agreed to be feted at a commemorative concert celebrating his 30th anniversary as a recording artist.  An extraordinary array of artists descended on Madison Square Garden to perform 30 Dylan songs from throughout his career — hits and obscure tracks, chestnuts and recent tunes.  Among the 75 different musicians and singers on stage at various points of the evening that night were Stevie Wonder, Lou Reed, Chrissie Hynde, Richie Havens, Johnny Winter, Tracy Chapman, Eddie Vedder, Johnny Cash, Mary Chapin-Carpenter and John Mellencamp.  As the show drew to a close, Dylan came out to perform three songs, and the best of these, the prescient “My Back Pages,” featured Roger McGuinn, Tom Petty, Neil Young, Eric Clapton, George Harrison and Dylan each taking a verse.  It’s a thrilling confluence of talent sharing the spotlight on an iconic song from 1964. The CD was released in 1993, with a deluxe CD/DVD package re-released in 2014.

***************************